The four dreams of nationalism: Our United Kingdom will not be united for much longer

by Alex Niven

This article was originally published in The New Statesman and is part of Alameda’s ‘After Orders’ project

___

May 2026 will be defined by nationalism

___

Nationalism, we are told, defines our age. At any rate, it seems likely to have defined these May elections. In Scotland, there is a strong possibility – at the time of writing – that the Scottish National Party will emerge with a majority in the Holyrood parliament for the first time since 2011. Reform surged in popularity ahead of the Senedd elections, but Plaid Cymru looks like it will be the dominant force in Wales, one way or another. If we include Sinn Féin’s sway over the Northern Ireland Assembly, then the United Kingdom may be confronted with the heady prospect of the three devolved governments being controlled by – or at least challenged by – explicitly anti-unionist parties for the first time.

These parties are moving in parallel, if not quite in alliance: the SNP First Minister, John Swinney, said on 22 April that he would “enjoy the cooperation” with Plaid and Sinn Féin should his party win. “I think the UK would be changed irreversibly if that outcome was to be the case,” Swinney said. Meanwhile, in England – the historical motherland of British unionism – there is a contrasting blend of ambiguity and rancour about the whole question of nationhood. This may well be the age of the lamp-post flagpole and the performative patriot. But at a fundamental level there is widespread confusion over matters of constitution and English identity.

_

Subscribe to read the full article.

images

Alex Niven

Alex Niven is an editor and writer from Newcastle upon Tyne. He wrote a PhD at the University of Oxford on modernist poetry and is the author of books including Folk Opposition, Definitely Maybe 33 1/3 and New Model Island, as well as articles for publications including The Guardian, The New York Times, New Statesman, New Left Review and Pitchfork. He co-founded the publisher Repeater Books and the pop band Everything Everything, and his book The North Will Rise Again inspired the name of the winning team at the inaugural litter picking World Cup in 2023.

RELATED ARTICLES

Episode 6: Domination Without Hegemony / with Juliano Fiori

May 12, 2026 ___ In the latest episode of After Order, a podcast series from Alameda in collaboration with Macrodose, — host James Meadway is joined by Juliano Fiori to reflect on the central premise of the series so far:…

Episode 5:  Power in the Periphery w/ Gabriel Tupinambá

May 6, 2026 ___ What does sovereignty look like when the structures that once sustained it begin to erode? In the fifth episode of After Order — a podcast series by Alameda in collaboration with Macrodose — the focus turns…

Towards a Concept of Ecological Sovereignty [After Order Working Paper Series]

May 6, 2026 ___ What would it mean to rethink sovereignty through an ecological lens? Join us online for the first event in Alameda’s After Order Working Paper Series. In this session, Sabrina Fernandes, Alameda Senior Leadership Fellow, will present…